CATEGORIES

Refined by:

Clear all
4 products

Availability

Price
The highest price is $ 32.00
$
To
$
Filter and sort Filter
Filter and sort
Filter
Refined by: Clear all

4 results

CATEGORIES
Availability
Price

The highest price is $ 32.00

$
To
$
Clear all
View as
Items per page
24
Sort by:
Alphabetically, A-Z

Butter Toffee

Toffee is Andy's baby — buttery, crunchy, refined batch after batch until it hits the same spot every time.

The secret's in the snap

Classic English toffee with one refinement of our own: it breaks with a clean, light snap instead of a tooth-sticking chew, so the slow-caramelized butter flavor reaches you faster. How we get there stays in our kitchen — but it's a big reason the toffee keeps winning awards.

How we make it

Cooked in our toffee kettle, poured into sheet pans, leveled and cooled, cut into squares, and enrobed one piece at a time.

Our toffees

Sea Salt Chocolate Butter Toffee (the classic), White Chocolate Cloister Honey Toffee (about a tenth of the sugar swapped for our local Cloister Honey — chewier, sweeter, under a white-chocolate coat), and Milk Chocolate Hazelnut Butter Toffee. New to it? The Toffee Sampler has all three.

See also our caramels or the full chocolate gifts collection.
  • Milk Chocolate Hazelnut Butter Toffee broken into rough pieces with chopped hazelnuts across the milk chocolate. Main image Milk Chocolate Hazelnut Butter Toffee Secondary image
    Milk Chocolate Hazelnut Butter Toffee
    Taking our award winning sea salt butter toffee, and many customer suggestions we wrapped it in our milk chocolate then give it a generous helping of toasted hazelnuts to create something equally delicious to try. We have a special toffee recipe that has been...
    From $ 8.00 USD
    From $ 8.00 USD (-0%)
  • Stack of Sea Salt Chocolate Butter Toffee slabs, the buttery toffee visible beneath the dark chocolate-and-sea-salt finish. Main image Sea Salt Chocolate Butter Toffee Secondary image
    Sea Salt Chocolate Butter Toffee
    Slowly caramelized butter and sugar can create a most marvelous experience. We have worked very hard at capturing that experience so you can enjoy it as well. Our toffee is easily crunchable by design so it breaks up easier, sticks to your teeth less,...
    From $ 8.00 USD
    From $ 8.00 USD (-0%)
  • Toffee Sampler Gift Set with milk chocolate toffees and white chocolate honey toffees stacked together in the box. Main image
    The Toffee Sampler
    Discover all three of our award-winning toffees in one gift-ready sampler. Each set includes three 4oz servings—Dark Chocolate Sea Salt, White Chocolate Honey, and Milk Chocolate Hazelnut. Every batch starts with slow-caramelized butter and sugar, cooked to a crisp, easy-to-enjoy snap that won’t stick...
    $ 27.00 USD
    $ 27.00 USD (-0%)
  • White Chocolate Cloister Honey Toffee broken into pieces, the buttery honey toffee enrobed in white chocolate. Main image White Chocolate Cloister Honey Toffee Secondary image
    White Chocolate Cloister Honey Toffee
    One of our passions is always local and you can't get much more local to us than the neighborhood down the block and their excellent bee keepers at Cloister Honey. Their local wildflower honey is excellent. With a cloying aroma and hints of hops...
    From $ 8.00 USD
    From $ 8.00 USD (-0%)

Recently viewed products